The Review

“Gwen and Art Are Not in Love” offers a captivating blend of genres, weaving a queer medieval rom-com with skillful narrative execution. Contrary to my initial assumption, this novel isn’t a retelling of the classic Arthurian love triangle but focuses on the unsatisfactory betrothal between Arthur of Maidvale, King Arthur’s descendant, and Gwendolyn, the Princess of England.

Throughout the first 70% of the story, a delightful humor permeates the narrative, making it a highly enjoyable read. The alternating perspectives of Gwendolyn and Arthur allow readers to intimately know the diverse ensemble of characters. The banter between Gwen and Arthur, though occasionally irksome, contributes to an engaging chemistry. Notably, Arthur’s camaraderie with his steadfast friend Sid is a standout element, portraying loyalty and wit.

Character development is a notable strength, particularly in Gwen’s transformation from a judgmental introvert to a more nuanced individual forging deeper connections. Bridget, the woman knight, stands out for her unwavering determination and refusal to conform to societal expectations.

However, the narrative takes an unexpected turn in the final 30%, introducing darker themes such as a brutal off-page attack and heightened violence. While plausible in hindsight, this tonal shift lacks seamless integration, creating a sense of abruptness. The departure from the initially lighthearted ambiance prompts contemplation on the author’s stylistic choices.

In summary, Lex Croucher’s debut navigates themes of coming of age, friendship, and self-acceptance with humor and heart-wrenching depth. The unforeseen narrative shifts and political elements may challenge readers seeking a consistent tone. Nonetheless, “Gwen and Art Are Not in Love” merits consideration as a commendable 3.5-star read in the realm of modern medieval romance.

---

Short Review (AKA TLDR)

Lex Croucher’s debut offers a refreshing twist on Arthurian lore, diverging from conventional retellings. The narrative’s humor and character dynamics shine, but a sudden dark turn in the final stretch may catch readers off guard. Despite some tonal inconsistencies, it remains a commendable 3.5-star read, exploring themes of friendship and self-acceptance within a modern medieval context.